award-winning roofing contractor
get a free quote

Roofing Blog

Roofer installing and securing corrugated roofing sheets with a hammer.

Composition vs. Metal Roofing in the Willamette Valley: Pros and Cons

What sort of roof should be over your head? Is composition shingle or metal the wiser way to go for an Oregon winter? And which is going to put the best value on your dollar?

We have been fielding such questions at River Roofing since 1971. Operating out of Springfield we cover the Southern Willamette Valley, having put more than 45,000 roofs in place in Eugene, Cottage Grove, Junction City, Veneta, Vida, Pleasant Hill, Creswell, Lowell and other towns. For a direct answer on your home you can ring us at (541) 782-7672. But let us run down the two most popular options first.

Why the Willamette Valley Climate Matters

It is well to consider what our local weather does to a roof before you select a material. We have our share of rain and long damp, gray days, not to mention moss and the odd snow or ice. A roof in this part of the country has to shed water, put up with the moisture year after year and stand off the moss.

Composition and metal will both get it done, but they do so in their own fashion. That makes a difference in cost, in how long it lasts and in the appearance of the house.

Composition Shingles: The Pros and Cons

You will see composition, or asphalt, shingles on most homes in the Eugene and Springfield area. There is good reason for that.

The case for composition roofing is made by these points:

  • It costs less up front than most metal
  • Plenty of styles and colors to suit your home
  • Installation is quick and simple
  • If some shingles are damaged the repair is easy and inexpensive
  • Contractors know the materials and they are easy to come by

Then there are the disadvantages to consider:

  • You are looking at decades of life, not a lifetime as with metal
  • Our climate encourages more moss and algae
  • Hard wind or debris can cause damage
  • You may have to put in a new one sooner than if it were metal

For a lot of homeowners it is the sensible, budgetary option. It is good looking and protective and a fix is no trouble when required.

Metal Roofing: The Pros and Cons

More and more homes in the Valley are sporting standing seam and metal panel roofs, not just the barns and shops.

Those who opt for metal do so for:

  • A service life that puts several composition roofs to shame
  • The way it sheds rain and snow
  • Better natural resistance to moss and algae than asphalt
  • Durability against the wind and fire
  • Little maintenance needed down the road
  • A modern look

But to be frank there are downsides:

  • The initial price tag is higher
  • You need a specialist with the right tools to install it
  • Damaged panels are more of a chore to put right
  • Without the underlayment some can be noisy in a hard rain

Metal is more expensive to begin with, but its longevity and lack of upkeep can make it worth it over time. On a home you intend to have for a number of years the numbers work out.

Which One Is Right for Your Home?

Every house is different. What is best for you will turn on your budget, the style you like, the state of the roof and how long you mean to be here.

Ask yourself:

  • How many years of ownership are in your plan?
  • What is your budget now and in the future?
  • Are you after the lowest cost or the longest life?
  • Which is in keeping with the neighborhood?

We can give you an unvarnished view of what is sensible. We do replacement, repair and new work on commercial and residential roofs alike.

Talk to a Local Roofing Team You Can Trust

River Roofing has been a name people in Lane County have put their trust in for over fifty years. We are licensed and insured, an A+ rated operation with the Better Business Bureau and a team of 45 plus. We also like to support giving in the community.

If you are of two minds between composition and metal, we will put together a free estimate to help you make up your mind. Call us at (541) 782-7672 any weekday from 7:30am to 4:00pm for a plain answer on the roof that suits you.

get a free
quote today!